Hockey Helmet vs Football Helmet : Which One is Better?

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

As winter approaches, many sports enthusiasts are gearing up for their favorite cold-weather activities. Two popular sports that require helmets to keep players safe are Hockey helmet vs Football helmet. While both helmets serve the same purpose of protecting the head from injury, they have some significant differences in design and function.

In this blog post, we’ll take a closer look at the hockey helmet vs football helmet debate and explore which one is better suited for its respective sport. So let’s dive into it!

Product Details Price
Bauer IMS 5.0 Hockey Helmet, Senior Brand– Generic Color– Black
Size– Small- Special Feature– Adjustable Strap Item Dimensions LxWxH
Bauer IMS 5.0 Hockey Helmet Combo with Facemask, Senior Brand– Generic- Color– Black
Size– Small- Special Feature
Adjustable Strap- Item Dimensions LxWxH
CCM Tacks 70 Hockey Helmet Combo with Cage Brand– Generic, Color– Black
Size– Senior Small, Special Feature– Lightweight, Model Name– CCM Tacks 70
CCM Tacks 70 Hockey Helmet Brand– Generic, Color– Black
Size– Senior Small, Special Feature– Lightweight, Model Name– CCM Tacks 7
Franklin Sports Youth Hockey Goalie Masks -Street Hockey Goalie Mask for Kids – GFM1500 Size– One Size- Color– Multi
Material– Plastic- Brand– Franklin Sports
Sport– Hockey
Bauer Prodigy Hockey Helmet Combo with Cage, Youth Size Brand– Generic, Color– Black
Age Range (Description)– 4-7 yrs old
Size– Youth, Model Name– Prodigy
MyLec Pro Helmet with Chin Strap, Lightweight & Durable Brand– Mylec, Color– Black
Age Range (Description)– Adult,
Size– Large
Razor V-17 Youth Multi-Sport Helmet Brand– Razor, Color– Gloss Black
Age Range (Description)– Youth,Teen,12 Years & Up, Size– Youth, Special Feature– Adjustable Strap

Comparison Table Of Hockey Helmet vs Football Helmet

FeatureHockey HelmetFootball Helmet
DesignLower profile, open-face structure with chin strap, caged-front, protects against sticks, pucks, and body collisions.Larger structure enclosing the entire head, padded face mask, protects against tackles and high-impact collisions.
Safety StandardsMust meet the standards set by Hockey Equipment Certification Council (HECC), Canadian Standards Association (CSA), or European CE.Football helmets must adhere to the safety standards established by the National Operating Committee on Standards for Athletic Equipment (NOCSAE).
MaterialMainly composed of vinyl nitrile foam padding and a hard, impact-resistant plastic shell.Typically, a hard polycarbonate or ABS shell with cushioned foam or air pad interior.
Face ProtectionCaged-front or half-shield visor protects the face, provides better visibility.Rigid, padded face mask covers the full face with small openings for visibility and breathing.
WeightGenerally lightweight (~750g) to allow for quicker movement and agility on ice.Heavier, with various weights between 3 to 6 pounds, focusing on protection against high impact.
AdjustabilityAdjustable straps and ratchet systems to ensure a snug fit.Customizable interior padding and adjustable chin straps to fit various head sizes.

History of Hockey Helmets

The history of hockey helmets is a fascinating one that dates back to the early 1900s. In the early days of hockey, players did not wear any protective gear on their heads, leaving them vulnerable to serious head injuries.

It wasn’t until the 1920s that players began experimenting with different types of head protection. Some wore simple leather caps or padded hats, while others used nothing at all.

The first true hockey helmet was designed by George Owen in 1928. Made out of fiberglass and cork, it covered the entire head and included earflaps for added protection.

Over time, advancements were made in helmet design and materials. Helmets became more streamlined and lightweight, allowing for better movement on the ice.

Today’s modern hockey helmets are made from high-impact plastics and feature multiple layers of foam padding for maximum protection. They also often include additional features such as ventilation systems to keep players cool during intense games.

While there will always be debate over whether or not helmets should be mandatory in hockey, one thing is certain: they have come a long way since their humble beginnings nearly a century ago.

History of Football Helmets

Football helmets have come a long way since the early days of the sport. In fact, football was played for over 50 years before helmets were even introduced! The first helmets used in football were made of leather and offered very little protection compared to modern day helmets.

It wasn’t until the 1940s that hard plastic helmets with face masks became standard in professional football. These new designs greatly reduced head injuries and changed the game forever.

In the following decades, helmet technology continued to improve, adding features like padding and ventilation to make them safer and more comfortable for players.

One notable moment in football helmet history came in 1971 when Pittsburgh Steelers player Ernie Holmes wore a painted gold helmet during Super Bowl IX. This started a trend among players customizing their own helmets with unique designs and colors.

Today’s football helmets are highly advanced pieces of equipment designed using computer simulations and impact testing to provide maximum protection against head injuries. Despite this progress, there is still much work to be done towards making the sport as safe as possible for all who play it.

Hockey Helmets

Hockey helmets are an essential piece of equipment for any hockey player, from beginners to professionals. They have come a long way since the first players started wearing them in the early 1900s. Today’s hockey helmets are designed with safety and performance in mind.

One of the most important features of a hockey helmet is its ability to protect the head from impact. Modern helmets use advanced materials such as ABS plastic, polycarbonate, and foam padding to absorb impacts and prevent injuries. Many also feature facemasks or cages that protect players’ faces from pucks and sticks.

In addition to protection, comfort is also a crucial factor when it comes to choosing a hockey helmet. Helmets should fit snugly but comfortably on the head without causing discomfort or pressure points.

Another consideration when choosing a helmet is ventilation. Hockey can be an intense sport, so proper ventilation helps prevent overheating during play.

Investing in a high-quality hockey helmet is essential for anyone who plays this fast-paced and physical game. With advancements in technology and design constantly evolving, there has never been a better time to prioritize safety on the ice with your choice of gear!

Football Helmets

Football helmets have come a long way since they were first introduced in the early 1900s. In those days, football players wore leather caps to protect their heads from injuries during games. However, as the game became more aggressive and physical over time, it was clear that better protection was needed.

In the late 1940s, plastic helmets started being used by football players for extra head protection. These early designs were quite simple and consisted of just a hard outer shell with some cushioning on the inside. Since then, engineering advancements and research have led to modern-day football helmets that are highly specialized in terms of design and safety features.

Today’s football helmets are made up of various components such as an outer shell made of polycarbonate material for maximum impact resistance, multiple layers of padding for shock absorption, face masks made of durable metals or plastics to protect against facial injuries, chin straps to keep them securely in place during gameplay and air vents to promote ventilation.

Despite all these innovations in helmet technology designed specifically for football players’ needs; there is still room for improvement when it comes to preventing concussions and other serious head injuries from occurring on the field.

Pros and Cons of hockey helmet and football helmet

Hockey helmet vs football helmet are designed differently according to the needs of each sport. Here are some pros and cons of each helmet type.

Hockey Helmets:


 – Hockey helmets provide full coverage to protect the head, face, ears, and neck.
– They have a cage or visor that protects the player’s eyes from injury.
– They are lightweight for easy movement during play.


– The thick padding can cause discomfort or overheating.
– The cage or visor can obstruct vision if not properly adjusted.
– Can be expensive if you want higher-end models with advanced features.

Football Helmets:


– Football helmets also cover the entire head but have a larger front area for impact protection.
– They feature a facemask as well as jaw pads to protect against collisions and tackles.
– Many models now come equipped with technology to absorb shock and reduce concussion risk.


– Their weight is heavier than hockey helmets which may cause fatigue in long games.
– The large size makes it more difficult to move around quickly on the field especially when running at full speed.
– A poorly fitted helmet increases your chance of injury so proper fitting is crucial.

Both hockey helmet vs football helmet offer unique advantages depending on their intended use. It’s important that players choose a quality helmet appropriate for their sport while ensuring they fit correctly for maximum protection without sacrificing comfort.

Similarities Between Hockey and Football Helmets

Hockey helmet vs football helmet may seem different on the surface, but they have several similarities. Both types of helmets are designed to protect players from head injuries while playing their respective sports.

One similarity between hockey helmet vs football helmet is that they both have a hard outer shell made of plastic or composite materials. This shell serves as the first line of defense against impacts to the head.

Another similarity is that both types of helmets feature padding on the inside to cushion any blows to the head. This padding helps absorb shock and reduce the risk of concussion.

Both hockey and football helmets also utilize a chin strap system to keep them securely in place during play. The chin straps help ensure that the helmet stays put even when a player takes a hit from an opponent or falls down on the ice or field.

Both types of helmets must meet certain safety standards set by organizations such as NOCSAE (National Operating Committee on Standards for Athletic Equipment) or HECC (Hockey Equipment Certification Council). These standards ensure that each helmet provides adequate protection for players when worn correctly.

Despite these similarities, there are notable differences between hockey and football helmets that make each type unique in its own way.

How to choose the right helmet for you

Choosing the right helmet is crucial for your safety and comfort during sports activities. Here are some factors to consider when selecting a helmet:


Your helmet should fit snugly on your head without being too tight or loose. It should stay in place even when you move.


Look for helmets made of high-quality materials that can absorb impact and protect your head from injury.


Check if the helmet has been certified by relevant authorities, such as the National Operating Committee on Standards for Athletic Equipment (NOCSAE).


Consider helmets with good ventilation to keep you cool and prevent overheating during intense activities.


Choose a style that suits your preferences and needs, whether it be an open-face or full-face design.

Remember to always prioritize safety over looks when choosing a helmet, and make sure to replace it if it becomes damaged or worn out over time.

Differences Between Hockey and Football Helmets

Hockey and football are two completely different sports, which means the helmets used in each sport have their own unique characteristics. While both helmets offer protection from head injuries, they differ in a number of ways.

Firstly, hockey helmets sit higher on the head compared to football helmets. This is because hockey players are more susceptible to hits from sticks and pucks rather than direct blows to the head like in football. Additionally, hockey helmets feature a cage that covers the player’s face for added protection against high-speed objects.

Secondly, football helmets have larger facemasks with thicker bars due to the physical nature of tackling and blocking in football. The padded interior also differs between sports as it is designed specifically for the type of impact it needs to absorb.

Ventilation systems vary greatly between hockey and football helmets. Hockey players require less ventilation since they play in colder environments while football players need better air flow during hot weather conditions.

Understanding these differences can help determine which helmet is best suited for each individual athlete based on their sport-specific needs.

Which One Is Better?

When it comes to the question of which helmet is better, it ultimately depends on the sport you are playing. Hockey and football helmets both have their own unique features that make them effective in their respective sports.

Hockey helmets are designed to protect against high-impact hits from sticks and pucks. They also provide ample ventilation to keep players cool during intense games. Football helmets, on the other hand, are made to absorb impacts from collisions with other players while keeping a player’s head stable.

One advantage hockey helmets have over football helmets is their full-face shields. This protects players’ faces from errant pucks or sticks flying at high speeds. However, this feature can also cause visibility issues for some players.

Football helmets often come equipped with additional padding around the jawline and neck area for added support in tackling situations. This can help prevent concussions caused by whiplash effects when a player is tackled.

Ultimately, choosing the right helmet comes down to personal preference and safety needs based on the sport being played. It’s important for athletes at all levels to prioritize proper protective gear in order to minimize risk of injury while playing either hockey or football.

FAQs related to Hockey Helmet vs. Football Helmet

1. Which is safer: a hockey helmet or a football helmet?

It is difficult to compare the safety of these two helmets as they are designed for different sports with distinct types of impacts. Both types of helmets follow specific safety standards according to their respective sports and offer protection for the risks inherent in each sport.

2. Can I use a hockey helmet for playing football or vice versa?

It is not recommended to wear a hockey helmet for football or a football helmet for hockey due to the different designs and protection levels tailored to each sport. Each helmet is crafted to mitigate sport-specific risks, and using the wrong helmet can leave you vulnerable.

3. How often should I replace my hockey or football helmet?

Both helmets should be replaced every few years, depending on usage and any noticeable damage. Most governing bodies recommend replacing hockey helmets every 6.5 years, while football helmet guidelines suggest reconditioning or replacing them every year for optimal protection.

4. Can I add a visor or cage to my football helmet for extra protection?

While it might be tempting to attach additional face protection, it is not recommended to modify football helmets in any way. Doing so can impact the safety certification or overall effectiveness of the helmet. Instead, consider other certified gear designed explicitly for football-related protection.

5. How important is the helmet fitment for both hockey and football?

Proper fitment is crucial for both types of helmets to function optimally. Each helmet should fit snugly without causing discomfort or limiting mobility. A poorly fitted helmet can slide during play and may fail to provide the intended level of protection against impacts.

6. What is the primary difference in the protection offered by hockey and football helmets?

The main difference lies in the nature of the impacts that each sport presents. Hockey helmets protect against high-speed collisions with the boards, pucks, and sticks. Football helmets, on the other hand, are designed to provide protection against high-impact helmet-to-helmet collisions, body tackles, and ground impacts common in the sport.


After analyzing the history, design, pros and cons of both hockey helmet vs football helmet, it is clear that they have their own unique features. Hockey helmets are designed to protect against different types of impacts than football helmets. Football helmets provide more protection for the face while hockey helmets prioritize protecting the top and back of the head.

When choosing a helmet for either sport, it’s important to consider your individual needs and playing style. It’s also important to choose a helmet that meets safety standards set forth by organizations like NOCSAE or CSA.

Whether you’re on ice or turf, protecting your head is essential in any contact sport. Both hockey helmet vs football helmet offer valuable protection but have their differences. Choose wisely based on what matters most to you: impact resistance or full-face coverage?

Nazrul Islam: Nazrul is an established author and the esteemed Sports Editor of the ADT Canada Russia Challenge. His passion for sports journalism is evident in each article he crafts, giving life to statistics and scores.
Related Post